Get in touch

What Do I Serve at a Murder Mystery Party?

So you’ve been invited to a murder mystery party. How exciting! Once you’ve had a chance to let that sink in, you’ll need to figure out the particulars, like how to dress. Fortunately, we're here to guide you through the art of selecting the ideal outfit for your murder mystery soirée.

Traditional Sit-Down Dinner

The traditional sit-down dinner approach adds an air of elegance and refinement to your murder mystery party. It's perfect for those who love a classic touch of sophistication. Consider serving a three-course meal with appetizers, a sumptuous main course, and delectable desserts.

Pro Tip: Tailor your menu to match the theme of your murder mystery. For example, if you're hosting a 1920s gangster-themed party, think of classic dishes like shrimp cocktail and filet mignon.

Buffet or Potluck-Style Dining

Are you looking for a more relaxed and interactive dining experience? Opt for a buffet or potluck-style meal. This approach allows guests to serve themselves and encourages mingling. Ask your guests to bring a dish, making it a true potluck feast.

Pro Tip: To ensure variety, assign different categories like appetizers, mains, sides, and desserts to your guests when coordinating the potluck.

Themed Finger Foods and Small Bites

For a modern twist on murder mystery party dining, consider serving themed finger foods and small bites. These convenient options keep your guests mobile and ready for mystery-solving action.

Pro Tip: Tailor your menu to match the theme of your murder mystery. For example, if you're hosting a 1920s gangster-themed party, think of classic dishes like shrimp cocktail and filet mignon.

Mystery-Inspired Cocktails and Mocktails

A well-crafted cocktail or mocktail can enhance the theme of your murder mystery party. Shake up some mystery-inspired drinks and serve them with a flourish.

Pro Tip: Craft a signature cocktail or mocktail for each character in your murder mystery. This adds a layer of immersion and fun to your event.

Catering Services and Professional Bartenders

If you're looking for a hassle-free option, consider hiring professional catering services or a bartender. They can create custom menus and handle the entire dining and beverage experience, leaving you free to focus on the mystery.

Pro Tip: Research local catering companies and bartenders with experience in themed events. Collaborate with them to design a menu that complements your murder mystery theme.

DIY Decor and Presentation

TNo matter which dining approach you choose, the presentation is key. Create an immersive atmosphere by paying attention to decor, table settings, and themed props.

Pro Tip: Use crime scene tape as table runners, magnifying glasses as centerpieces, and personalized place cards with character names for an immersive experience.

Incorporating creative food and drink ideas into your murder mystery party can elevate the overall experience for you and your guests. Whether you opt for a traditional sit-down dinner, a buffet-style feast, or mystery-inspired cocktails, the key is to align your choices with the theme and atmosphere you want to create. So, get ready to whet your guests' appetites for intrigue and excitement at your next murder mystery soirée! Don't forget to share your own culinary and mixology triumphs with us. Cheers to a night of mystery and delight!

Want to Throw Your Own Party?

If you’ve been considering throwing a murder mystery party, but need a little guidance, send us a message and one of our experienced party planners will get in touch with you. Our team will talk you through the details of what’s sure to be a murderous good time!

We're Hiring! The Murder Mystery Co. is seeking candidates to fill the permanent, full-time role of Inside Sales Representative in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Learn More/Apply Now
Employment Opportunities